How to Make Pottery Barn-Inspired Smiling Jack-O’-Lantern Pillows for Halloween

Create your own copycat Jack-O’-Lantern Pillows, inspired by Pottery Barn’s version. A fun DIY craft project for Halloween, to scare up some smiles and save money too. 🎃

DIY Copycat Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

Happy Monday!

Calling all Halloween lovers, I’m sharing a fun craft project you can make

in the comfort of your AC when it’s hot and steamy outside.

DIY Copycat Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

If you’re a regular reader, you know my love of Halloween.

🎃  ☠️ 👻 🍁  🧹🍬 🕸️ 🎃

Jack-O'-Lantern Pillows Pottery Barn

I loved these smiling Jack-O’-Lantern Pillows that I saw online from Pottery Barn,

but not the $79 price tag per pillow.

DIY Pottery Barn-inspired Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

Here are the easy steps to make an affordable copycat JOL pillow

if you’d like to make one or two to scare up some smiles. ;)

🎃 🎃

Transform sweater and fabric pumpkins into copycat Pottery Barn-inspired Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I spied these pumpkin pillows at Hobby Lobby. All Hobby Lobby’s fall merchandise is 40% off.

The larger cream sweater pumpkin was $25.99

and the brown smaller pumpkin pillow was $12.99,

so together they were around $23, after the discount.

Jack-O'-Lantern template for Pottery Barn-inspired pillow for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I searched online for a Jack-O’-Lantern template.

I like to keep the ‘Happy’ in Halloween so I wanted a smiling Jack rather than a scary one.

 You can download my printable JOL template, HERE.

Scale it to the size you need, I used it at 75% and 60% to fit my pumpkin pillows.

DIY Pottery Barn-inspired Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I cut out the eyes, nose and smiling mouth of my printed template and positioned

them on my pumpkin pillows using straight pins.

DIY Pottery Barn-inspired Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I used some black yarn and a yarn needle (I used size 13) to stitch

around the cut out features. After I got the outline stitched,

I removed the straight pins and templates.

Stitch a Jack-O'-Lantern face with yarn on a sweater pumpkin pillow for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

Then it’s just a matter of stitching in the features with yarn on face of your Jack-O’-Lantern.

It only took a couple of hours while watching TV

to stitch the eyes, nose and mouth of both pillows.

Stitch a Jack-O'-Lantern face with yarn on a sweater pumpkin pillow for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I decided the pumpkin stems could use some embellishing,

so I used some wired hemp / grapevine wire leftover from my

DIY Cornucopia Centerpiece for Thanksgiving.

DIY Pottery Barn-inspired Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

To make pumpkin stem / vine tendrils,

I wrapped the wire around a pencil to make some curlicues.

To cut the wire you’ll need a pair of side cutting pliers.

How to make pumpkin vine tendrils with grapevine wire #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I wrapped the grapevine wire and tendris around the stems of the pumpkin to attach it.

DIY Pottery Barn-inspired Jack-O'-Lantern PIllows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I added another Halloween pillow to my porch!

I laughed outloud when I saw this skeleton pillow with dangly legs at Michaels.

Use your Michaels weekly coupon to save 40%

Jack-O'-Lantern and Skeleton pillows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

I thought my skeleton crew, Rod and Rowena, would get a kick out of it too.

Skeleton pillow with dangling legs for Halloween

Looking for more DIY Halloween craft projects?

You might also like:

DIY Halloween Treat Cones, as fun to make as they are to receive! Affordable to scare up using scrapbook paper for Halloween party favors #diy #halloween #craft

DIY Halloween Treat Cones

As fun to make as they are to receive! Affordable to scare up using scrapbook paper for Halloween party favors

or as a table decoration to add some nostalgia or bit of vintage charm.

DIY Halloween Candy Boo-quet! Create a sweet candy boo-quet for Halloween for a table centerpiece and little ghouls and goblins. #diy #halloween #craft

DIY Halloween Candy Boo-quet

Create a sweet candy boo-quet for Halloween for a table centerpiece and little ghouls and goblins.

DIY Umbrella Floating Witch! Celebrate Halloween with a fun little “witch craft” and conjure a floating witch using an umbrella from the dollar store. #diy #halloween #craft

DIY Umbrella Floating Witch

Celebrate Halloween with a fun little “witch craft” and conjure a floating witch

using an umbrella from the dollar store.

Witch Shoe Candy Bowl! Use an easy trick for your Halloween treats candy bowl and to elevate the fun. #diy #halloween #craft

Witch Shoe Candy Bowl

Use an easy trick for your Halloween treats candy bowl and to elevate the fun.

Jack-O'-Lantern and Skeleton pillows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

🎃  ☠️ 👻 🍁  🧹🍬 🕸️ 🎃

How to Make Pottery Barn-Inspired Smiling Jack-O'-Lantern Pillows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase anything through an affiliate link, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

How to Make Pottery Barn-Inspired Smiling Jack-O'-Lantern Pillows for Halloween #diy #halloween #craft #pumpkin

Thank you for your visit, sharing with:

Between Naps on the Porch


Discover more from Home is Where the Boat Is

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

  22 comments for “How to Make Pottery Barn-Inspired Smiling Jack-O’-Lantern Pillows for Halloween

  1. Rita C.
    August 21, 2023 at 7:16 am

    Adorable, affordable – love it! Rod & Rowena will be excited for heads and legs to roll around them. 💀🦴🎃

  2. Pam
    August 21, 2023 at 7:22 am

    Mary, how cute are the DIY JOL’s! Much more affordable than the PB’s. My grands would love them! Happy Monday.

  3. Cheryl
    August 21, 2023 at 7:53 am

    You are so clever, Mary! I love this idea! 🧡

  4. Mary Anne
    August 21, 2023 at 8:16 am

    Its NEVER TO EARLY FOR HALLOWEEN!!!! Thanks for a fun project to help all of us get ready! YOU ARE AMAZiNG. Thanks for they joy you bring!

  5. Cindi
    August 21, 2023 at 8:36 am

    I usually want summer to last and last but this year I am so ready for Autumn and that means Halloween! Will have to make the jack o lantern pillows and every year I think about your witch leg umbrella so this might be the year I attempt that. Your creativity knows no boundaries so thank you for sharing all your ideas. Peace

  6. Clara
    August 21, 2023 at 9:11 am

    Mary, those are so cute! The skeleton one cracks me up! I made some pumpkin pillows out of old cable knit sweaters a few seasons ago. Now I’m going to add a jack o lantern face to the larger ones. What a cute and inexpensive idea! Thanks for the inspiration. Happy Monday. Clara❤️

  7. August 21, 2023 at 9:33 am

    These are adorable Mary, and yours are much cuter than PB’s!! They made me instantly smile! Great tutorial too, and I love the curly vines you added. The skeleton pillow is super cute too, I know Rod and Rowena will love it! 🎃

  8. Debbie
    August 21, 2023 at 9:58 am

    These are so dang cute! What a great idea, thanks for sharing.

  9. August 21, 2023 at 10:25 am

    Very cute pumpkin faced pillows Mary. I love saving money and your tutorial is spot on. The Skelton pillow makes me chuckle. A great way to start my morning with your cute Halloween craft.

  10. Barbara
    August 21, 2023 at 11:46 am

    Wow Amazing, Mary, So darn cute.

  11. Beverly E.
    August 21, 2023 at 12:05 pm

    So creative! Just the thing to kick off the Halloween season. I am soo ready for Fall!

  12. Sue
    August 21, 2023 at 1:41 pm

    I share your love for Halloween and you never fail to offer fantastic ideas. Just the other day I was looking forward to your Halloween posts! So happy it was sooner than I expected! Thanks,

  13. Sheryl R
    August 21, 2023 at 2:55 pm

    Great idea and another great tutorial for the Jack O Lantern pumpkin pillows!! They came out so cute! I can’t wait to see what antics Rod and Rowena will involve themselves in this year!! They are favorites of mine! I LOVE your blog, Mary!

  14. August 21, 2023 at 5:07 pm

    Your copycat JOL Pottery Barn pillows are just too cute, Mary! Did you buy the skeleton pillow for Rod and Rowena? I’ll look forward to some antics from them. I hope you’ll have a wonderful week. I’m still sweltering. 😘

  15. Kim
    August 21, 2023 at 10:33 pm

    These are adorable Mary – what a great PB knock-off. (I think yours are cuter). I agree that $79 per JOL pillow is downright scary. Can’t wait to see Rod and Rowena’s reaction to the new pillows! Such fun and a great tutorial.

  16. August 22, 2023 at 9:22 am

    I get such a kick out if your constant creativity 😎

  17. August 22, 2023 at 2:48 pm

    Of course you made your own! You are great at thinking out of the box, and yours are adorable! Well done!
    Thanks for all the other craft ideas. I’m not a crafty one, but I still like to look at these clever projects. I file them away “just in case” I get my craft on! Happy Halloween!

  18. Shannon@Belle Bleu Interiors
    August 22, 2023 at 10:13 pm

    Mary, your Jack-o-lantern pillows are adorable! They are just as cute as the expensive Pottery Barn pillows. Thanks for giving us such great step by step instructions. This is a perfect craft for staying indoors during these triple digit days.

  19. Cyndi Raines
    August 23, 2023 at 12:45 am

    Cute, cute, cute! You are so smart Mary. Thank you for the smiling template! Such a bargain shopping at Hobby Lobby and yours are darling! Did I tell you I planted 4 pumpkin starter plants and I now have 2 large pumpkins , 4 medium, but still growing daily and 3 babies coming! I check the “nursery” daily and am So Excited! You should add a pumpkin patch next year to your awesome garden. You will be over the moon with joy at how easy and fun! Highly recommended for pumpkin lovers! 😁

  20. Cyndi Raines
    August 23, 2023 at 12:53 am

    P.s. I just remembered the 18th was a special day… I think your anniversary, so belated wishes to you both. God bless. (Or If your birthday, blessings to you!). My memory hasn’t been the same since my honey passed. 😕

  21. Heritage Hall
    September 9, 2023 at 12:04 am

    Skeleton saga a scream…thanks for the laughter, Mary. You are so gifted…..

Leave a Reply to DebbieCancel reply

Discover more from Home is Where the Boat Is

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Discover more from Home is Where the Boat Is

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading