It is labor intensive, but Oh-So-Good and a favorite
for us when tomatoes runneth over!
Food Network’s recipe has a cornmeal crust which we love, but you could use a prepared pie crust to save prep time.
I usually make the crust a day in advance or the morning of, and wrap the pastry disk in plastic, refrigerating until I’m ready to make the pie.
I decided to make individual pies
or tarts with the recipe and
4.75-inch Wilton Tart/Quiche Pans.
To save time, I caramelize the onion a day or two in advance, for the filling. I also mix my other filling ingredients in advance and set aside in the refrigerator until I’m ready to assemble.
Food Network’s directions call for slicing tomatoes, tossing with salt and placing in a colander to drain for 30 minutes.
I have better luck placing tomato slices on layers of paper towels and leaving them to stand, occasionally replacing the paper towels for an 1 1/2 to 2 hours.
What I love about this tomato pie recipe besides the cornmeal crust, is that is not too mayonnaise-y, only 1/4 cup in the filling along with the onion, shredded mozzarella and manchego cheese, bread crumbs, and herbs~ chopped chives, parsley, and thyme.
The recipe made five individual 4″ pies or tarts.
You can find the printable recipe from Food Network here.
If your tomato cup runneth over, try this recipe!
It’s ideal too for those heirlooms that won’t win any beauty contests but are full of flavor :)
Beautiful presentation! I love ketchup, but won’t eat a tomato, lol!
I make them for dh though. One he likes is baked in a casserole with feta and shrimp. Good sale on shrimp this week, I will have to make it!
Your pies look wonderful! Enjoy your crop.
Oh how I love tomatoes — and heirlooms are the very best!! Your comment about the beauty contest is funny, but so true. When I look at tomatoes, if they look too perfect, I’m not interested because I feel like they won’t have a lot of flavor. Just like those kind in cellophane at the supermarket. :)
The pictures of your food are just gorgeous and mouth watering! I’ve been wanting to make a tomato pie; I’ve eaten them before but never made one myself. I’ll have to check out this recipe; I’m so glad you shared it.
Your post is beautiful, as always. I hope you’re having a good weekend, Mary, and staying cool.
Good morning, Mary! Just yesterday, Yvonne and I went to a TOMATO FARM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Talk about your tomatoes runneth over!!!! AISLES of tomatoes!!!! I have red and yellow grape tomatoes and some beautiful slicing tomatoes. This week they will be on MY menu. Thanks so much for sharing these recipes and your beautiful table. Love the arrangement. XO, Pinky PS, those tomato plates are fabulous. I remember them.
Oh yum! Your tomato pies are gorgeous Mary, I’d love some! The little purple tomatoes are cool. I had a tomato sandwich, actually forgot about a BLT… how could I forget about bacon??? Happy Weekend:@)
This looks so good, Mary. We found someone selling heirloom tomatoes as we were leaving for the lake Thursday. We had some of them for breakfast this morning, with fresh caught crappie from the lake. Yum :-).
Ah, tomatoes….one of my most favorite foods…ever! So wonderful when they are just picked from the vines! Got some glorious heirloom ones yesterday afternoon at a little ‘flash market’ just a few miles from our house…also got some tiny mini grape ones which I will use today in a ‘tomato cocktail’…Tomatoes are summer’s richest rewards…but what is wonderful is that we can grow them year ’round! Beautiful photos, as usual, Mary…and I am saving this recipe to make soon… A few years ago I made a Ratatouille Quiche that was to die for…
I love your idea of making little individual pies for everyone! I will have to look for those pans. My favorite heirlooms are the purple cherokees and a close second would be lemon boys. I have eaten so many tomatoes this summer I should turn into a tomato!
All your tomatoes looks so delicious. We eat them like apples around there. We have bought 3 huge cases, but not for canning, just for eating, and we ate every one! I love your centerpiece – and the Pokeberries:)
Your tomatoes dishes and recipes look delicious. The tomato pie is my favorite and I would love to make this recipe. Thanks for sharing. Have a wonderful week ahead.
So far my tomatoes are still all green, but I am hoping for great things!! I have pinned your delicious featured recipe, and will be using it when mine ripen. Thank you so much!
Love your tomato centerpiece! It inspired a vegetable centerpiece I recently did for a summer party, the guests had a fit over the fresh veggies instead of flowers. Can’t wait to try the individual tomato tarts, they look amazing!
I am putting those tart pans on the Christmas wish list and the recipe on the recipe board. When you add to that the wonderful quote from Thoreau, which I love and plan to use now, you just have a wonderful all around post here.
This whole tomato tablescape is marvelous! You have taken tomatoes to a whole other level!!!! YOur tomato tart is a must try! Thanks for sharing at ON THE MENU MONDAY!
You entire tablesetting with all the tomatoes is gorgeous. I love it. Plus the recipes sound soooooooo good. I definitely will give them a try. Thanks for joining TTT. Hugs, Marty
Our tomatoes are just starting to come in now and I can’t wait to try your tomato tart recipe! We had our first BLTs the night before last with our first BIG tomato – delicious! Gorgeous table and I love that centerpiece :) Great pics and attention to detail as always.
Your tomato arrangement is so rich and luscious. It could be a still life painting. The recipes sound delicious. I have a friend who grew an heirloom tomato called Cherokee Purple, and it was the most delicious tomato I have ever tasted. Thanks for the great post.
Oh my goodness! We have gone a little crazy with tomatoes ourselves this year! There is absolutely nothing like home grown garden fresh tomatoes!! Wonderful presentation Mary!! As you can see, I am catching up with all of the posts I have missed!!
Mary….I have been so out of blogging the last few months and am finally getting back to see my favorites. And of course you are at the top of the list!! Love your tomato tartes and table. So delicious looking and the table so inviting!!! So excited to see everything else you’ve dones these last months. Know that you truly do inspire me!! N.
One word for this – LOVE! Have been away from blogging for a little while. Decided to look at your lemon rosemary pound cake email today and you have me hooked. Using the pokeweed with the tomatoes for the table arrangement is just genius! I may need to borrow that for the garden club.
Beautiful presentation! I love ketchup, but won’t eat a tomato, lol!
I make them for dh though. One he likes is baked in a casserole with feta and shrimp. Good sale on shrimp this week, I will have to make it!
Your pies look wonderful! Enjoy your crop.
Hi Mary,
Oh how I love tomatoes — and heirlooms are the very best!! Your comment about the beauty contest is funny, but so true. When I look at tomatoes, if they look too perfect, I’m not interested because I feel like they won’t have a lot of flavor. Just like those kind in cellophane at the supermarket. :)
The pictures of your food are just gorgeous and mouth watering! I’ve been wanting to make a tomato pie; I’ve eaten them before but never made one myself. I’ll have to check out this recipe; I’m so glad you shared it.
Your post is beautiful, as always. I hope you’re having a good weekend, Mary, and staying cool.
Hugs,
Denise
Good morning, Mary! Just yesterday, Yvonne and I went to a TOMATO FARM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Talk about your tomatoes runneth over!!!! AISLES of tomatoes!!!! I have red and yellow grape tomatoes and some beautiful slicing tomatoes. This week they will be on MY menu. Thanks so much for sharing these recipes and your beautiful table. Love the arrangement. XO, Pinky PS, those tomato plates are fabulous. I remember them.
That was a feast for the eyes as well as a feast for the imagination!
Oh yum! Your tomato pies are gorgeous Mary, I’d love some! The little purple tomatoes are cool. I had a tomato sandwich, actually forgot about a BLT… how could I forget about bacon??? Happy Weekend:@)
This looks so good, Mary. We found someone selling heirloom tomatoes as we were leaving for the lake Thursday. We had some of them for breakfast this morning, with fresh caught crappie from the lake. Yum :-).
Oh how I love fresh, garden raised tomatoes. How sad I am when tomato season is over. My mouth watered all the way through your beautiful post.
Just lost my comment! ;-)
But I said…….not a fan of tomatoes, but these pies would grab my attention. Beautiful post, Mary, and gorgeous wicker table.
Ah, tomatoes….one of my most favorite foods…ever! So wonderful when they are just picked from the vines! Got some glorious heirloom ones yesterday afternoon at a little ‘flash market’ just a few miles from our house…also got some tiny mini grape ones which I will use today in a ‘tomato cocktail’…Tomatoes are summer’s richest rewards…but what is wonderful is that we can grow them year ’round! Beautiful photos, as usual, Mary…and I am saving this recipe to make soon… A few years ago I made a Ratatouille Quiche that was to die for…
This looks delicious! Wish we had tomatoes this year, the drought has hampered growing in West Texas! Thanks for sharing the beautiful tablescapes!
Wow, what a delicious and beautiful post! I am definitely going to make that tomato salad when it gets a bit warmer here in Australia!
Best wishes,
Natasha in Oz
I love your idea of making little individual pies for everyone! I will have to look for those pans. My favorite heirlooms are the purple cherokees and a close second would be lemon boys. I have eaten so many tomatoes this summer I should turn into a tomato!
Wow ~ does this ever look delicious and pretty too!
Hugs,
Susan and Bentley
Your pies look wonderful! Yum, I would love to be tasting some right now!
Such an attractive centerpiece- I love fresh things. Great tablescape as usual and pictures make my mouth water.
The pie looks quite interesting. A bit different.
– The Tablescaper
All your tomatoes looks so delicious. We eat them like apples around there. We have bought 3 huge cases, but not for canning, just for eating, and we ate every one! I love your centerpiece – and the Pokeberries:)
Your tomatoes dishes and recipes look delicious. The tomato pie is my favorite and I would love to make this recipe. Thanks for sharing. Have a wonderful week ahead.
So far my tomatoes are still all green, but I am hoping for great things!! I have pinned your delicious featured recipe, and will be using it when mine ripen. Thank you so much!
Love your tomato centerpiece! It inspired a vegetable centerpiece I recently did for a summer party, the guests had a fit over the fresh veggies instead of flowers. Can’t wait to try the individual tomato tarts, they look amazing!
So glad to hear you are planting hydrangeas!!! Can’t wait to see them next year!!!!
I am putting those tart pans on the Christmas wish list and the recipe on the recipe board. When you add to that the wonderful quote from Thoreau, which I love and plan to use now, you just have a wonderful all around post here.
This whole tomato tablescape is marvelous! You have taken tomatoes to a whole other level!!!! YOur tomato tart is a must try! Thanks for sharing at ON THE MENU MONDAY!
Mary….great recipe and I am in love with that “tomato centerpiece”…gorgeous!!…A true work of art!
You entire tablesetting with all the tomatoes is gorgeous. I love it. Plus the recipes sound soooooooo good. I definitely will give them a try. Thanks for joining TTT. Hugs, Marty
Our tomatoes are just starting to come in now and I can’t wait to try your tomato tart recipe! We had our first BLTs the night before last with our first BIG tomato – delicious! Gorgeous table and I love that centerpiece :) Great pics and attention to detail as always.
Your tomato arrangement is so rich and luscious. It could be a still life painting. The recipes sound delicious. I have a friend who grew an heirloom tomato called Cherokee Purple, and it was the most delicious tomato I have ever tasted. Thanks for the great post.
Just delicious to see your tomato tarts – exquisite little works of art.
Beautiful photography. The colours are magnificent.
Kelly
Love the idea of individual tarts and I just happen to have those little tart pans. This would make a wonderful luncheon entree’ pared with a salad.
Oh my goodness! We have gone a little crazy with tomatoes ourselves this year! There is absolutely nothing like home grown garden fresh tomatoes!! Wonderful presentation Mary!! As you can see, I am catching up with all of the posts I have missed!!
Mary….I have been so out of blogging the last few months and am finally getting back to see my favorites. And of course you are at the top of the list!! Love your tomato tartes and table. So delicious looking and the table so inviting!!! So excited to see everything else you’ve dones these last months. Know that you truly do inspire me!! N.
One word for this – LOVE! Have been away from blogging for a little while. Decided to look at your lemon rosemary pound cake email today and you have me hooked. Using the pokeweed with the tomatoes for the table arrangement is just genius! I may need to borrow that for the garden club.
Beautiful pictures!! Tomatoes look amazing I am jealous :)
Mary I have never seen a prettier tomato post! Your food is gorgeous!